Share
Accounts on the OBSSR e-Learning site enable you to save notes as you read the contents of the site.  Notes are a way for you to save a spot on the site with your own comments and title applied to it.  Think of it as putting a sticky note paper in a book to remember a place and leave a thought or two of your own for later reference.

Social and Behavioral Theories

6. Theory Use in Intervention Research

Recently, several reviews have examined which theories were used in health behavior intervention research and whether theory-based strategies are positively associated with desirable outcomes. Table 2 summarizes 11 systematic reviews published since 2000 – most within the past three years – that reported on theory use and in several cases, the effects of using theories for intervention design. They cover a range of behavioral topics: dietary fat and fruit and vegetable intake; cancer screening; injury prevention; HIV-related sexual risk behaviors; and contraception. These reviews also examined tailored print and computer-based interventions.

Table 2

Reviews of Theory Use in Health Behavior Intervention Research

Click on the table preview below to see the full table:

Table 1: Reviews of Theory Use in Health Behavior Intervention Research

Table 2

Reviews of Theory Use in Health Behavior Intervention Research

Article Topical Focus Theories Used Comments
Ammerman et al., 2002 Dietary fat, fruit and vegetable (F&V) consumption Theory use yes/no; SCT constructs (goal setting); social support Using a theoretical basis was associated with greater fat reduction and higher F&V intake Goal setting, family and social support strategies more effective
Legler et al., 2002 Mammography promotion in historically underserved groups Theory used in 68.4% of included studies. Most-used: HBM, TTM, SCT, PRECEDE/PROCEED Strongest interventions were access-enhancing, consistent with SCT, HBM and ecological model.
Trifiletti, Gielen, Sleet & Hopkins, 2005 Unintentional injury prevention research Most-used: TRA/TPB, HBM, PRECEDE/PROCEED Model. Theories were not well-represented in injury prevention research from 1980 to 2001
Noar, Benac & Harris, 2007 Tailored print health behavior change interventions TTM/stages of change, HBM, TRA/TPB, most used. Nearly every study tailored on at least one theoretical concept Tailoring with 4-5 concepts yielded larger effect sizes than tailoring on 0-3 concepts. Nearly all studies that tailored on theoretical constructs had larger effect sizes
Joronen, Rankin & Astedt-Kurki, 2008 School-based drama interventions SCT, TTM Use of social cognitive theory most common (role models, interaction, etc). Mostly positive effects found
Noar, 2008 Reducing HIV-related sexual risk behavior – review of 18 meta-analyses Most often mentioned: self-management, problem-solving training, skills training with SCT concepts 3 meta-analyses found theory-based strategies superior, 2 showed possible evidence, 2 were null or against theory-based components
Albada et al., 2009 Tailored information about cancer risk and screening Most-used were TTM, HBM, SCT, PAPM Review suggested that theory-based interventions are most effective
Lopez, Tolley, Grimes & Chen-Mok, 2009 Interventions for contraception (non-high-risk groups) SCT was the main theoretical basis in most trials Theory-based intervention groups had more positive results in majority of trials
Lustria, Cortese, Noar & Glueckauf, 2009 Computer-tailored interventions delivered over the web – various behaviors (diet, activity, alcohol, smoking) Most-used theories are SCT, TTM, TRA/TPB. Most studies indicated a theoretical framework. Use of multiple theories and concepts was common, because online computer-tailored strategies are more complex than print tailoring
Noar, Black, & Pierce, 2009 Computer technology-based HIV prevention interventions Theories used: SCT, TPB, Integrated Model of Behavior (IMB), TTM Interventions using TTM/stages of change and individual tailoring were most effective
Noar, Palmgreen et al., 2009 HIV/AIDS mass communication campaigns Mass communication theories used; message content based on HBM, SCT, TTM, TPB and others 44% of campaigns reported using theory, mainly for message design

** From Glanz & Bishop, Ann Rev PH 2010